I asked you about every girlfriend you’d ever had, my hand in yours as we walked over the Brooklyn Bridge. You never let me tell you about the people I slept with before you, which I was suppose is some classic romantic trope or something but it never suited me and I was dying to. I still hate you for that, and would quite like to send you a list, with footnotes concerning the number of orgasms gleaned from each, maybe how many times I went down on them, or where. You wouldn’t be able to unread it. So there’s always that to look forward to.
But it was dark and the weather was perfect and you didn’t tell me that’s where we were headed and right when I thought, hey! We should walk over the bridge! you turned to me and said, Hey! Do you want to walk over the bridge?
I did!
And you told me about your women and I loved every story you told, stopping to kiss you, reimagining your romantic narrative with me at the end, asking you if you touched her boob, if you saw her naked, if she was a good kisser, if she was as good of a kisser as me.
The wind was blowing and we would stop on the sidewalk and kiss; you’d lift me up in the air and kiss me, and I say this because it astounds me now, that moment before you disappoint each other, when you can stop mid sentence, overwhelmed with this, astonishment, Who are you?
It’s not that we really even want to know yet.
And when we walked home I start to tell you about the first boy I ever saw naked and you got mad and annoyed and I hated it. I want to be confessional, I want to be transcendent, I want to torture each other emotionally and cry and stay.
That night I think you let me tell you about the first boy. About Pete. I told you how I only knew his name when he asked me because I saw a drawing on his fridge, done in crayon and stick figures, addressed to Uncle Pete.
“Did you like it?” you asked. Did I? I don’t think I did, but I don’t think that’s what I was in it for. I liked that I knew, now.
Pete did something boring with money, I told you. He was a federal actuary, I remember that now, but I liked to remind you how boring I think money is, how different and creative I am.
I picked him up in a bar, I tell you, I was very drunk, I tell you, in a way I never am now, I tell you, because I’m afraid you won’t like that about me and I tell you that after I took a poll of the crowd— “Raise your hand if you’re a virgin!” no one raised their hand but me. Which was, of course, the deciding factor.
You told me always that I should set some goals. Make a list. You’d say this to me on the way to things, Tell me about your writing, you’d say, it’s the elephant in the room, you’d say, it’s who you are, and I’d let go of your hand on street corners and shake my head and look away and get very angry. How could I tell you, “It is very private.” “You wouldn’t understand.” “You don’t understand anything about me, and you never will. But we have excellent sex and you hold my hand and I would like to see how complicated we can make this.”
It is not something I can tell you about because I will need it for when you leave me.
So I told you that losing my virginity was simply a goal I had set and the time had come to check it off my to-do list. The sadness of that didn’t hit me until a few months later, in bed with another stranger I had picked up at another bar, an Italian, this one, who asked for my sexual origin story and held me and said that that was not how it should be, that I should have a boyfriend who loved me who I could make love to multiple times a day and who could teach me and help me learn what I liked, and, and, and. I cried in his arms and he ssshed me, kissing my back, telling me it was okay in his Roman accent. It wasn’t right, I thought, but it was true. What could I say? That no one showed up for me, that no one liked me enough, that maybe no one felt that I was worth the risk, so I took my own.
I shrugged to him and he told me I was beautiful and creeped down to the end of the bed and asked, “Can I eat you?” I still laugh when I think of it.
That night with Pete I was wearing these underwear with sparkly fireworks all over them that I got at Wal-Mart in the 7th grade. Really. I considered them my lucky underwear and I guess it held true, in a pile in his living room where Van Morrison was playing on a 6-cd changer and candles were half-lit. What are you doing, I demanded, as he lit them and I stood there alone, behind a loveseat.
It always felt very lonely, is what I wanted to tell you. And it didn’t with you.